...if it is closed off, as it happens most of the time. I’m speaking about tech, all kinds of devices and software, specifically.
I got sick and tired of seeing companies launching an ecosystem or adding yet another product
to the lineup.
My problem with that is, I think that a product should work regardless of the ecosystem.
Otherwise, it most likely will be a landfill in a month. Let’s take my favorite product: speakers. “Smart”
speakers, for that matter. Why are they “smart”? Because ecosystem!
Can I use HomePod with BlueTooth? I
can’t. Can I use some generic stupid ass shit bluetooth speakers from any device? Hell yes!
That’s where I
call out ecosystems bullshit as it is. Other “non-ecosystem”, “limited functionality”, “no magic” devices just
work with anything.
But there I’ll have to buy a whole lot of standalone products, which are useless on its
own. I can’t pair Apple Watch to an Android. I can’t transfer files between an iPhone and other non-apple
device. Is that what you call an ecosystem? I call it limitation and a failure.
Sure, most users, and more specifically Apple users won’t care about it, and will happily buy another Apple
product. But people on a tight budget or tech enthusiasts do care about this.
I can’t justify buying
a device which is useless, unless I buy 10 other devices to complement it.
With this approach comes
greediness: let’s make this device do that, but not the other, so that people will have motivation to buy all
of our stuff.
Fuck that.
More often than not ecosystem puts on more limitations than I would have if all devices would be regular
standalone products.
Some features that require an “ecosystem” just work like crap, so you would be even
better off without it. Apple’s Handoff, for example.
Apple’s ecosystem promises, or at least implies
synchronization between devices, but fails to do so in practice. I would even go as far as to say that it is
not practically possible today.
I can’t imagine any serious (or even a personal) project relying on software that runs only on one OS.
I can’t allow to be cut off. Hell, some of Apple’s own apps and a ton of third party apps are not crossplatform
because of some bizarre and stupid reasons. Where is the ecosystem if I can’t continue working on another
device?
What if my iPhone dies and I can’t access notes or projects in an Apple ecosystem exclusive app?
What if I decide to add non-Apple devices into the mix? The “magic” disappears.